Jumat, 26 Juni 2015

Business Law Assigment (Larasati Pingkan)

The Legal force to support  stabillity the effort

Business law is a legal instrument governing the procedures and implementation of a business or trading activity, industry, finance or related to the exchange of goods and services, production activities and events put the money made by the entrepreneur with the business and certain motifs which have considered all the risks that may occur.

Background of  business law
Born healthy economy through business activity, trade or business that is healthy. A healthy economic activity certainly have rules that guarantee a business, trade or business that is healthy.

A business rule or law is needed because: 
  1. parties involved in business requires something more formal is not just a promise or good faith.
  2. the need to create a legal remedy that can be used as it should be if one party does not fulfill the obligation or violate the agreement that has been agreed then the business law can be played as it should.

Business people need to know, understand and learn the business law for any business activity that does is set by law, so that its business activities do not violate the law and can derive the maximum benefit.


Functions of business law
Basically the law is made to create life in a society that is safe, orderly and peaceful, nor with business law. The function of business law diantarnya:
a. Become a useful source of information for businesses,
b. Provide an explanation of their rights and obligations in business practices,
c. Realize business activity, accompanied by the character and behavior of the perpetrators so as to create a sound business activities, dynamic and just because it is guaranteed by the rule of law.

The scope of business law
The scope of business law includes several things, including:
1. Business Contracts
2. Form a business entity (PT, Firma, CV)
3. Capital markets and companies going public
4. The trading activities by companies
5. Investment or investment
6. Liquidation and bankruptcy

7. Mergers, acquisitions and consolidation

8. Debt Guarantee
9. Marketable securities
1
0. Employment
1
1. Intellectual Property Industry
1
2. unfair competition and prohibition of monopoly
1
3. Protection of consumers 15. Distribution and agents
1
4. Taxation
1
5. Insurance
1
6. Resolving business disputes
17. International Business
18. Law of transport by land, sea, or air
19. Protection and guarantee legal certainty for users of technology and technology owners
2
0. Law of the industry or the processing industry.
Law
21. The activities include multinational companies export and import activities
22. Law of Mining Activities
2
3. Law of Banking and securities
2
4. Law Real estate, construction and housing
2
5. The international trade law or international agreements
2
6. Law on Money Laundering

Source Business Law
Sources of business law is the basis of the establishment of business law. Sources of business law include:
a. kotrak principle agreement between the parties involved which each party is subject to the rules that have been agreed.
b. The principle of freedom of contract where business people can create and determine the content of the agreement which they had agreed.
In general, according to sources of business law legislation, including
a. Civil Code (Civil Code)
b. Public Law (Economic criminal / Criminal Code)
c. Commercial Law (Code of Commerce)
d. Laws outside the Civil Code, Criminal Code, and Code of Commerce
While the sources of business law in the opinion of Munir Fuady, include: Legislation, agreements, treaties, jurisprudence, customs and doctrines of legal experts







COMPANY LAW
Introduction
Since the implementation of the 25-year economic  development-planning program, Indonesian economic growth can  be attributed to an increase in participation of small and large  business enterprises. Not only has there been an increase in assets
and capital accumulation, enlistment of human resources, but also business resources (which from time to time create a business cycle). One of the business entities
that dominate, in the Indonesian business sector, is the Limited Liability Company. As a created legal entity, it is necessary for an Indonesian Limited Liability Company to be supported not only by its own organs, but also by  Clear and concise regulations in order to maximize and utilize its organizational and managerial ability effectively and efficiently. Hence, strong and stable business entities are very important to
enhance national development. It istherefore necessary to have a brief overview of business organizations within the framework of Indonesian Company Law







Types of Business Organizations

Indonesia’s commercial sector recognizes three principal categories of business organizations: sole proprietorship, partnership (general or limited) and company. Sole proprietorship is generally used in the informal sector, since its nature and activities are of the informal sector. For example, it does not require formal registration to Indonesian authorities. There are three types of partnership: persekutuan perdata (maatschap or private association), persekutuan firma(venootschap onder firma or firma, “FA”) and
persekutuan komanditer(commanditaire vennootschap, “CV”).The Indonesian Civil Code
governs the first type of partnership whereas the rest are governed by both the Indonesian Civil Code and the Indonesian Commercial Code. It is not easy to determine
absolute equivalents between these partnerships and partnerships under common law tradition; however, the maatschapand firma closely resemble the concept of
a general partnership under the common law system whereas the commanditaire venootschapresembles limited partnership under common law.
The last type of business organization is under the Indonesian Company Law takes the form of Perseroan Terbatas (“PT”).It is similar to the incorporated limited liability company under the common law system. Historically, this was referred to as the Dutch corporate model known as the naamloze venootschap(“NV”). However, since the enactment of the new Indonesian Company Law, which repealed
the provisions governing the company, many companies started to
use the abbreviation “PT”.

THE LAW OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
NUMBER 40 OF 2007
CONCERNING
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
BY THE GRACE OF ALMIGHTY GOD
THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
Considering :
a. that the national economy, which is implemented based on economic democracy with the principles of community, fair efficiency, sustainability, environmental awareness, independence, and safeguards for balanced progress and national economic unity, needs to be supported by a strong economic institutions in the context of creating prosperity for community;
b. that in the context of increasing the national economic development and at the same time providing a strong foundation for the business world in facing the development of world economy and progress in science and technology in the coming globalization era, a support is needed to enact a law that regulates limited liability company which can assure the implementation of a conducive climate for the business world;
c. that a limited liability company as one of the national economic development pillars, need to be given a legal ground in order to accelerate more of the national development composed as a mutual effort based on the principle of family spirit;
d. that Law No. 1 of 1995 regarding Limited Liability Company is considered no longer in accordance with the legal developments and needs of society, so that it is deemed necessary to be replaced with a new law;
e. that based on the consideration as referred to in letter a, letter b, letter c, and letter d, it is necessary to form a Law on Limited Liability Company ;
In View of : Article 5 paragraph (1), Article 20, and Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia;
With the unanimous approval of
THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVE
And
THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
HAVING RESOLVED
To stipulate : A LAW ON LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY















CHAPTER I
GENERAL PROVISIONS
Article 1
In this law the following terms have the following meanings:
1. Limited Liability Company, hereinafter referred to as the Company, means a legal entity constitutes a capital alliance, established based on an agreement, in order to conduct business activities with the Company’s Authorized Capital divided into shares and which satisfies the requirements as stipulated in this Law, and it implementation regulations.
2. Company Organs means the General Meeting of Shareholders, the Board of Directors, and the Board of Commissioner.
3. Social and Environmental Responsibility means the commitment from Company to participate in the sustainable economic development, in order to increase the quality of life and environment, which will be valuable for the Company itself, the local community, and the society in general.
4. The General Meeting of Shareholders, hereinafter referred to as GMS, means the organ of the Company that has authority not given to the Board of Directors or the Board of Commissioners, within limits as stipulated in this Law, and/or the articles of association.
5. The Board of Directors means the organ of the Company that has the authority and full responsibility to manage the Company for the interest of the Company, in accordance with the purposes and objectives of the Company as well as to represent the Company, either in or out the court in accordance with the provisions of the articles of association.
6. The Board of Commissioners and the organ of the Company that has the responsibility to conduct a general and/or specific supervision , in accordance with the articles of association, as well as providing advice for Board of Directors.
7. Issuer means a Public Company or a Company which exercise a public offering to shares, in accordance with the provisions and legislations in the field of capital market.
8. Public Company means a Company which satisfies the criteria of numbers of shareholders numbers and amount of paid-up capital in accordance with the provisions and legislations in the field of capital market.
9. Merger means a legal action taken by one or more Companies in order to merge with another existing Company, which causes the transfer of assets and liabilities of the merging Companies by operation of law, to the surviving Company and thereafter the legal entity status of the merging Company ceases by operation of law.
10. Consolidation means a legal action taken by two or more Companies to consolidate themselves by establishing a new Company, which by operation of law obtains the assets and liabilities from the consolidating Companies, and the legal entity status of the consolidating Companies ceases by operation of law.
11. Acquisition means a legal action conducted by a legal entity or an individual to acquire the shares of the Company, resulting in the transfer of control of such Company.
12. Separation means a legal action taken by a Company in order to separate its businesses, which causes all assets and liabilities of the Company legally transferred to 2 (two) or more Companies, or part of the assets and liabilities of the Company legally transferred to 1 (one) or more Companies.
13. Registered Mail means a letter which is addressed to a recipient evidenced by a signed and the date receipt from the recipient.
14. Newspaper means a daily newspaper in Indonesian language with national circulation.
15. Day means a calendar day.
16. The minister means the minister whose tasks and responsibilities are in the field of law and human rights.
Article 2
The Company must have a purpose and objective as well as business activities that do not conflict with the legislative regulations, public order, and/or morality.
Article 3
(1) The Company’s Shareholders are not personally liable for agreements made on behalf of the Company, and are not liable for the Company’s losses in excess of their prospective shareholding.
(2) The provision as referred to in paragraph (1) do not apply if :
a. the requirements for the Company as a legal entity has not been or are not fulfilled;
b. the relevant shareholders, either directly or indirectly, with bad faith, exploits the Company for their personal interest;
c. the relevant shareholders are involved in illegal actions committed by the Company; or
d. the relevant Shareholders, either directly or indirectly, illegally utilizes the assets of the Company, which result in the Company’s assets become insufficient to settle the Company’s debt.
Article 4
This Law, the articles of association of the Company, and provisions of other legislations shall apply to the Company.
Article 5
(1) The Company shall have a name and domicile within the territory of the Republic of Indonesia, as determined in the articles of association.
(2) The Company shall have a full address in accordance with its domicile.
(3)  In correspondences, announcements published by the Company, printed materials, and deeds to which the Company is a party, the name and full address of the Company must be mentioned.
Article 6
The Company may be established within a limited period or unlimited period as stipulated in the articles of association.










CHAPTER II
THE ESTABLISHMENT, ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION AND AMENDMENTS OF ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION, REGISTRY OF COMPANY AND ANNOUNCEMENTS
Part 1
Establishment
Article 7
(1) The Company shall be established by 2 (two) or more persons based on a notarial deed drawn up in Indonesian language.
(2) Each founder of the Company is obliged to subscribe shares upon the establishment of the Company.
(3) The provision as referred to in paragraph (2) does not apply in the context of Consolidation.
(4) The Company obtains legal entity status on the date of the issuance of Ministerial Decree regarding the ratification of the Company’s legal entity.
(5) If after the Company obtains its legal entity status and the number of shareholders becomes less than 2 (two) persons, then within the period of not later than 6 (six) months as from such condition, the relevant shareholders is obliged to transfer part of their shares to other persons or the Company shall issue new shares to other persons.
(6) In the event that the time period as referred to in paragraph (5) has exceeded, and there is still less than 2 (two) shareholders, the shareholders shall be personally liable for all agreements/legal relationship and the Company’s loss, and upon the request of the interested party, the District Court may wind up the Company.
(7) The provision which requires the Company to be established by 2 (two) or more persons as referred to in paragraph (1), and the provision on paragraph (5), as well as paragraph (6) do not apply to :
a. State Owned Limited Liability Company; or
b. Companies managing security exchange, clearing house and underwriting, custodian and settlement institution, and other institutions regulated in the Law on Capital Market.
Article 8
(1) The deed of establishment shall set forth articles of association and other information related to the Company’s establishment.
(2) Other information as referred to in paragraph (1) shall contain at least:
a.  full name, place and date of birth, occupation, residential, and nationality of the individual founder, or name, domicile, and full address, as well as the number and date of the Ministerial Decree regarding the ratification of legal entity founders of the Company;
b.  full name, place and date of birth, occupation, residential, and nationality of the first members of the Board of Directors and the Board of Commissioners to be appointed.
c.  the name of the shareholders who have subscribed the shares, detail of the number of shares, and nominal value of shares subscribed and paid-up.
(3) In making the deed of establishment, the founder can be represented by other person by virtue of a Power of Attorney.
Article 9
(1) In order to obtain the Ministerial Decree regarding the ratification of the Company’s legal entity as referred to in Article 7 paragraph (4), the founders shall jointly submit an application through an electronic legal entity administration system information technology services to the Minister by filling up the form which shall contain at least the following :
a. The name and domicile of the Company;
b. The term of establishment of the Company;
c. The purpose and objective as well as business activities of the Company;
d. The amount of authorized capital, issued capital, and paid-up capital;
e. full address of the Company.
(2) Filling in the form as referred to in paragraph (1) must be preceded by the submission of the Company’s name.
(3) In the case the founders do not submit the application themselves as referred to in paragraph (1) and paragraph (2), the founder may only give power of attorney to a notary.
(4) Further provisions regarding the procedure of submission and use of the Company’s name will be stipulated by Government Regulation.
Article 10
(1) The application to obtain the Ministerial Decree as referred to in Article 9 paragraph (1), must be submitted to the Minister not later than 60 (sixty) days as of the signing date of the deed of establishment, complete with information on the supporting documents.
(2) The provision regarding the supporting documents as referred to in paragraph (1) shall be stipulated by a Minister Regulation.
(3) If the form as referred to in Article 9, paragraph (1) and the information on the supporting documents as referred to in paragraph (1) is in accordance with the provisions of the legislations, the Minister shall directly declare electronically that there is no objection to the relevant application.
(4) If the form format as referred to in Article 9 paragraph (1) and the information on the supporting documents as referred to in paragraph (1) is not in accordance with the provisions of the legislations, the Minister shall directly notify electronically of the rejection and the reasons therefore.
(5) Within the period not later than 30 (thirty) days as of the non-objection statement date as referred to in paragraph (3), the relevant applicant is obliged to physically submit an application letter with a supporting documents attached.
(6) If all requirements as referred to in paragraph (5) have been fully fulfilled not later than 14 (fourteen) days, the Minister shall issue a decree regarding the ratification of the Company as a legal entity which is signed electronically.
(7) If the requirements regarding the period and the completeness of the supporting documents as referred to in paragraph (5) are not fulfilled, the Minister shall directly notify the matter to the applicant electronically, and the statement of no objection as referred to in paragraph (3) shall become null.
(8) In the event that the statement of no objection is null, the applicant as referred to in paragraph (5) may re-submit an application in order to obtain the Decree from the Minister as referred to in Article 9, paragraph (1).
(9) In the event that the application to obtain the Ministerial Decree is not submitted within the period as referred to in paragraph (1), the deed of establishment shall be void as from the lapse of such period and the Company which does not yet have legal entity status shall be dissolved by operation of law, and the settlement shall be conducted by the founders.
(10) The provision on the period as referred to in paragraph (1), shall also apply for a re-submission.
Article 11
      Further provisions regarding submission of application to obtain the Ministerial Decree as referred to in Article 7 paragraph (4) for certain areas that do not yet have or cannot use electronic network, shall be regulated in a Ministerial Regulation.
Article 12
(1) Legal actions relating to share ownership and to which payment is performed by a prospective founder prior the establishment of the Company, shall be stated in the deed of establishment.
(2) In the event of legal actions as referred to in paragraph (1) are stated in a deed which is not an authentic deed, such deed shall be attached to the deed of establishment.
(3) In the event of legal actions as referred to in paragraph (1) are stated in an authentic deed, the number, date and name as well as domicile of the Notary making such authentic deed shall be mentioned in the deed of establishment of the Company.
(4) In the event that the provisions as referred to in paragraph (1), (2), and (3) are not fulfilled, such legal actions shall not give rise to rights and obligations and shall not bind the Company.
Article 13
(1) Legal acts performed by the prospective founders for the interest of a Company which is has not yet been established, shall bind the Company after the Company becomes a legal entity if the first GMS of the Company explicitly states that it accepts or takes over all rights and obligations arising from the legal acts conducted by the prospective founders or its attorney.
(2) The first GMS as referred to in paragraph (1) shall be conducted not later than 60 (sixty) days after the Company obtains the status of legal entity.
(3) The resolution of the GMS as referred to in paragraph (2) is valid if the GMS is attended by the shareholders representing all shares with voting rights and the resolution is approved unanimously.
(4) In the event that the GMS is not held within the period as referred to in paragraph (2), or the GMS is failed to adopt the resolution as referred to in paragraph (3), each prospective founder exercising such legal actions shall be personally liable to the consequences arising.
(5) The GMS approval as referred to in paragraph (2) will not be necessary if such legal actions are performed or approved in writing by all prospective founders prior the establishment of the Company.
Article 14
(1) Legal actions on behalf of the Company which has not yet obtained the status of legal entity, may only be performed by all members of the Board of Directors together with all founders, as well as all members of the Board of Commissioners of the Company, and they will all be jointly and severally liable for such legal actions.
(2) In the event of such legal actions as referred to in paragraph (1) are performed by the founders on behalf of the Company which has not yet obtained the status of legal entity, the relevant founders shall be responsible for such legal actions and the legal actions shall not bind the Company.
(3) The legal actions as referred to in paragraph (1), by operation of law shall be the responsibility of the Company after the Company becomes a legal entity.
(4) The legal actions as referred to in paragraph (2) shall only be bound and shall be the responsibility of the Company after such legal actions are approved by all shareholders in the GMS attended by all shareholders of the Company.
(5) GMS as referred to in paragraph (4) is the first GMS which must be held not later than 60 (sixty) days after the Company obtains its legal entity status.
Part Two
Articles of Association and Amendment of Articles of Association
Paragraph 1
Articles of Association
Article 15
(1) Articles of association as referred to in Article 8 paragraph (1) shall contain at least :
a. The name and domicile of the Company;
b. The purposes and objectives as well as the business activities of the Company;
c. The period of incorporation of the Company;
d. The amount of authorized capital, issued capital, and paid-up capital;
e. The number of shares, shares classification if any, including the number of shares for each classification, the rights attached to each share, and nominal value of each share;
f. The name of title or position and the number of members of the Board of Directors and the Board of Commissioners;
g. The determination of the place and procedures for holding a GMS;
h. The procedures of appointment, replacement, and dismissal of the members of the Board of Directors and the Board of Commissioners;
i. The procedure for profit utilization and dividend distribution.
(2) Apart from the provisions as referred to in paragraph (1), the articles of association may also contain other provisions which do not conflict with this Law.
(3) The articles of association may not contain:
a. provisions concerning receipt of fixed interest on shares; or
b. provisions concerning the grant of personal benefits to the founders or other parties




In Article 15 letter b of Law 25/2007 stipulated that every investor is obliged to implement TJSL. What is meant by TJSL according to the elucidation of Article 15 paragraph b of Law 25/2007 is the responsibility inherent in each investment firm to keep creating relationships harmonious, balanced, and in accordance with the environment, values, norms, and local culture.
While the definition of investor is an individual or business entity that makes an investment that can be either domestic investors and foreign investors ( Article 1 paragraph 4 of Law 25/2007 ).
In addition in Article 16 of Law 25/2007 also stipulated that every investor is responsible to preserve the environment. It is also part of TJSL.
If the investor does not perform its obligation to carry out TJSL, then under Article 34 of Law 25/2007, investors may be subject to sanctions in the form adminisitatif:
a.     written warning;
b.     restrictions on business activities;
c.     Suspension of business and / or investment facility; or
d.     revocation of business activities and / or investment facility.
In addition to administrative sanction, investors also may be subject to other sanctions in accordance with the provisions of the legislation ( Article 34 paragraph (3) of Law 25/2007 ).


Law No. 32 of 2009 on the Protection and Management of the Environment ("Law 32/2009")

Pursuant to Article 68 of Law 32/2009, any person doing business and / or activity must:

a. provide information relating to environmental protection and management of true, accurate, transparent, and timely;

b. maintaining the sustainability of environmental functions; and

c. comply with the provisions on environmental quality standards and / or standard criteria of environmental damage

  

Upstream activities undertaken by business entities or permanent establishment under the Cooperation Contract with the Implementing Body shall contain the principal provisions, one of which is the provision regarding the development of the surrounding communities and guarantees the rights of indigenous peoples (Article 11 paragraph (3) letter p Law 22/2001).
In addition in Article 40 paragraph (5) of Law 22/2001, also said that business entities or permanent establishments that carry out business activities of Oil and Gas (upstream activities and downstream activities) take responsibility in developing the environment and local communities.
See the provisions above, it can be seen that there are indeed rules that require companies to build communities around.
Thus the answer from us, may be useful.
Legal Basis:
6.     Regulation of the State Minister for State-Owned Enterprises No. PER-05 / MBU / 2007 2007 About the Partnership Program With State Owned Small Business and Community Development Program, as last amended by Regulation of the Minister of State-Owned Enterprises No. PER-08 / MBU / 2013 Year 2013 On the Fourth Amendment to the Regulation of the State Minister for State-Owned Enterprises No. PER-05 / MBU / 2007 on Partnership Program With State Owned Small Business and Community Development Program.












EXAMPLES OF BUSINESS ETHICS VIOLATION CASES

(About Corporate Social Responsibility / CSR)

According to the theory of Business Ethics
 The underlying thought CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility), which is often considered to be the core of Business Ethics is that the company not only have obligations economical and legal (meaning to shareholders or shareholder) but also the obligations of the other parties concerned (stakeholders ) whose scope exceeds the above obligations. Some things that are included in this CSR include the management of the company (corporate governance) are now emerging in Indonesia, the company will be environmental awareness, workplace conditions and standards for employees, company-community relations, corporate social investment (corporate philanthropic).

Conformity According to the PP Act
 According to Government Regulation No. 27 of 2012 on Environmental Permit. The development process undertaken by the Indonesian people should be held based on the principle of sustainable development and environmentally sound in accordance with the mandate of Article 33 paragraph (4) of the Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia Year 1945. Development activities are carried out in various forms of Business and / or activities will basically impact on the environment. With the implementation of the principles of environmentally sustainable development in the implementation process, the impact on the environment caused by construction activities will be analyzed early planning stages, so that the negative impact of control measures and the development of positive impact can be prepared as early as possible. Device or instrument that can be used to do that is EIA and UKL-UPL. Article 22 of Law No. 32 of 2009 on the Protection and Management of the Environment stipulates that every effort and / or activities that have an important impact on the environment must have EIA.

Case Analysis
 In the newspaper
 Jawa Pos, May 2, 2013,
 there is one article that I think violates Business Ethics, namely article entitled
"Without a license, reckless Three Factory Activity"
, The three categories are in Gresik, PT. BKP (Edible Oil Manufacturers), PT. IDM (Fish Processing), and PT. HNF (Industrial Equipment). These industries are considered to violate Business Ethics in Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) as three potentially emit hazardous waste. Not only that, they also do not have licensing documents environmental impact assessment (EIA), they simply piggyback on the EIA establishment owned Gresik Industrial Estate (KIG). Other companies that violate business ethics in CSR, namely PT. BKP (oil producers) that permits amdalnya not yet clear and many times these companies reported local residents as often pollute the environment. There is also PT. IDM is often complained for causing the smell.

Suggestion
 The government must be firm action against industries that do not have a full license, which can be especially detrimental to society and have a direct impact on the surrounding environment. And perform the inspection and supervision of new industries to be established.

The case of bussines in indonesia

Has many case in indonesia like for the poor people didn’t want help that think the law of bussnies is didn’t good princip because the sistematic still bad like in this case


Bayi Meninggal Setelah Ditolak 10 Rumah Sakit

Bayi Meninggal Setelah Ditolak 10 Rumah Sakit  

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Dera Nur Anggraini, bayi yang baru berusia enam hari, meninggal lantaran sakit pada saluran pencernaannya. Ironisnya, Dera meninggal setelah ditolak oleh 10 rumah sakit yang diminta menangani operasinya

That’s really bad  about the law in indonesia because just care with a rich man.











Case 3

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiIyfmxvf6Y9U0g6cZCO2Hlansuqar1MNpQ321MjfS9IzeNRlWl1u_612pSCrKw4YL30tvxcWlz0hIELeTp8niknyZ3SyQAfBfo6O66wVjlhWPaUgUO5iYcD2zxQaa2neDlAysHTRQjZfs/s1600/buah+disuntik2.jpg
Hati-hati jika hendak membeli buah durian. Sejumlah pedagang durian di sepanjang Jalan Lintas Timur (Jalintim), Lampung Timur melakukan praktek tidak terpuji. Mereka menjual buah durian yang terlebih dahulu disuntik zat pemanis.

Like in this case really bad if eats with consumen because has bad subtance for consumes














The solution

I think for goverment must has good The Legal force for the poor people like in medicine because the the poor people same with another people they like consumers too and must has consumer protection and must get right behavior from goverment exam. But many worker in company didnt same right behavior to poor people, the company must give direction to worker that is must same treat  to another people. And the consumer must get protection to the  bad seller like sells the bad fruit because that’s really danger to the consumer health and really bad if the consume is child, and to another people if wants consumen because if we didnt consumen the bad food or fruit that will lessen the fraudulent seller and the goverment must obserrve the fraudulent seller.


Conclusion


My conclusion about the consumen must smart to buy something, because in new global has many naughty seller  and for the legal force must has more confirmation to the fraudulent seller.